• Latest
  • Trending
  • All
  • News
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Science
  • World
  • Lifestyle
  • Tech

Judiciary PS Bigirimana Wins Defamation Suit

December 10, 2021
Stanbic, Cinemax 190-day promo gives 20% discounts on FlexiPay, Visa Card payments

Stanbic, Cinemax 190-day promo gives 20% discounts on FlexiPay, Visa Card payments

December 4, 2023
COP28: Global and African partners pledge $175m to the Alliance for Green Infrastructure in Africa (AGIA)

COP28: Global and African partners pledge $175m to the Alliance for Green Infrastructure in Africa (AGIA)

December 4, 2023
Who is Makata, new chief finance and value management offcier

Who is Makata, new chief finance and value management offcier

December 4, 2023
Airtel Uganda Unveils First 5G Home Broadband Device with Promise to Boost  Connectivity in Uganda

Airtel Uganda Unveils First 5G Home Broadband Device with Promise to Boost Connectivity in Uganda

December 2, 2023
Stanbic advocates transparency for traders dealing with financial institutions

Stanbic advocates transparency for traders dealing with financial institutions

December 2, 2023
Law society punches holes in the rule of law report as Mao assures of improvement

Law society punches holes in the rule of law report as Mao assures of improvement

December 2, 2023
Advertisers and marketers urged to embrace technology, or face extinction

Advertisers and marketers urged to embrace technology, or face extinction

December 2, 2023
BII announces a $6.7 million investment in  wind farms in South Africa

BII announces a $6.7 million investment in wind farms in South Africa

December 1, 2023
COP28: Govt fronts hydropower generation, peace and security to woe UAE to invest in Uganda

COP28: Govt fronts hydropower generation, peace and security to woe UAE to invest in Uganda

December 1, 2023
UIA cleared to represent Uganda at COP28 in UAE

UIA cleared to represent Uganda at COP28 in UAE

November 17, 2023
ADVERTISEMENT
News 24/7
  • Home
  • News
    • All
    • Business
    • Politics
    • Science
    • World
    Stanbic, Cinemax 190-day promo gives 20% discounts on FlexiPay, Visa Card payments

    Stanbic, Cinemax 190-day promo gives 20% discounts on FlexiPay, Visa Card payments

    Who is Makata, new chief finance and value management offcier

    Who is Makata, new chief finance and value management offcier

    Airtel Uganda Unveils First 5G Home Broadband Device with Promise to Boost  Connectivity in Uganda

    Airtel Uganda Unveils First 5G Home Broadband Device with Promise to Boost Connectivity in Uganda

    Stanbic advocates transparency for traders dealing with financial institutions

    Stanbic advocates transparency for traders dealing with financial institutions

    Law society punches holes in the rule of law report as Mao assures of improvement

    Law society punches holes in the rule of law report as Mao assures of improvement

    Advertisers and marketers urged to embrace technology, or face extinction

    Advertisers and marketers urged to embrace technology, or face extinction

    BII announces a $6.7 million investment in  wind farms in South Africa

    BII announces a $6.7 million investment in wind farms in South Africa

    COP28: Govt fronts hydropower generation, peace and security to woe UAE to invest in Uganda

    COP28: Govt fronts hydropower generation, peace and security to woe UAE to invest in Uganda

    UIA cleared to represent Uganda at COP28 in UAE

    UIA cleared to represent Uganda at COP28 in UAE

    MILESTONE: UIA wins International Award to Boost Investment in Uganda

    MILESTONE: UIA wins International Award to Boost Investment in Uganda

    Trending Tags

    • Donald Trump
    • Future of News
    • Climate Change
    • Market Stories
    • Election Results
    • Flat Earth
  • Entertainment
    • All
    • Gaming
    • Movie
    • Music
    • Sports
    The weekend weekly wrap up

    The weekend weekly wrap up

    Butiki league gathers throngs matches expectations

    Butiki league gathers throngs matches expectations

    Natete United Triumphs as champions in the inaugural break free edition

    Natete United Triumphs as champions in the inaugural break free edition

    Sheebah, Cindy trade in a word of war ahead of their battle show

    Sheebah, Cindy trade in a word of war ahead of their battle show

    Wrap up of the weekend NBL games

    Wrap up of the weekend NBA games

    I hope to be remembered as a Rubaga boy who embraced music and cherished his country-Navio

    I hope to be remembered as a Rubaga boy who embraced music and cherished his country-Navio

    Wrap up of the weekend NBL games

    The midweek excite as teams put up decent display

    Sir Apollo Kaggwa Schools holds musical production to showcase students’ talents

    Sir Apollo Kaggwa Schools holds musical production to showcase students’ talents

    Wrap up of the weekend NBL games

    Wrap up of the weekend NBL games

    Ex UPDF soldier guards me -Alien Skin

    Ex UPDF soldier guards me -Alien Skin

  • Watch Now
  • Sports
  • Shot Stories
  • Fact Checker
No Result
View All Result
News 24/7
No Result
View All Result
Home court

Judiciary PS Bigirimana Wins Defamation Suit

Dorothy Nalumansi by Dorothy Nalumansi
December 10, 2021
in court, News, Politics
Reading Time: 6 mins read
0
ADVERTISEMENT

“What made it even grave is that the said money was meant for Northern Uganda post-war rehabilitation, the said region having gone through decades of war and trauma. Any person believed to have tampered with the said aid, in the eyes of reasonable and right thinking members of society would be equated to a mass murderer”, said Justice Ssekaana.

ADVERTISEMENT
The Judiciary Permanent Secretary Pius Bigirimana.

The High Court in Kampala has ordered the Monitor Publications Limited to pay 450 million shillings to the Judiciary’s Permanent Secretary Pius Bigirimana for defamation.

The head of Civil Division of the High Court Musa Ssekaana made the decision on Friday after finding that Monitor Publications together with four others jointly published 15 articles between 2012 and 2017 which the Judge has described as twisted, skewed and crafted in a manner that portrayed Bigirimana as the key suspect in the Office of the Prime Minister financial scam that was then under investigations.

ADVERTISEMENT

The four others are; The Managing DirectorMonitor Publications Limited, its Editor in Chief and the Editor for Sunday Monitor together with their reporter.

  The Judgement arises from a successful defamation suit filed by Bigirimana in 2017  saying that between 2012 and 2015, the respondents continuously made numerous malicious, spiteful, untrue and defamatory publications against him in the daily Monitor, Saturday Monitor and the Sunday Monitor.

  Although Bigirimana noted that 42 articles that were written around that time portraying him as an embattled civil servant who made illicit expenditure on OPM funds, a person who thrives on statehouse’s pampering and patronage, obstructs police investigations and above all, a liar, he was able to select 15 articles that he took to court and has succeeded.

Some of the articles bore titles such as “Auditors target Bigirimana in cash probe”; “Bigirimana’s wife acquires Shs 250m Mercedes Benz”; “Treasury Officials accuse OPM PS of covering money scam”; “MPs Order Government to remove Bigirimana”; “Denmark Warns of Aid Cut over OPM Scandal”; and “Corruption Ledger” among others.

  The court records show that the said stories generally talked about how more than 500 billion shillings’ donor funds meant for Northern Uganda post-war rehabilitation allegedly got lost in the hands and under the watch of Bigirimana who was the then Permanent Secretary of the Office of the Prime Minister.

Not happy with the articles, through his lawyer Godfrey Himbaza, Bigirimana petitioned court arguing that the said publications were false and intended to tarnish his name.

  According to Bigirimana, the then Director of Public Prosecutions, Justice Mike Chibita wrote a letter on May 28th 2019 clearing him and stating that in all the cases that have been prosecuted so far, his role was that of a complainant and prosecution witness. 

He added that the respondents did not reach up to him to verify the veracity of the said allegations, despite the fact that as a public servant he was accessible to anybody. But Instead, that the publications decided to go ahead and publish the stories wantonly without regard to the negative impact they would have on him.

 As such, court heard that the aforementioned articles in their natural and ordinary meaning, meant or were understood to mean in the minds of right thinking members of the public that;  

he is a person who is above the law with an untouchable mentality and personality; a person who obstructs the course of Justice; is culpable for fraud but disguises himself as a whistle blower; a person who thrives on presidential pampering and patronage among others.

  Because of the said publications, Bigirimana demanded for an apology and compensation saying he has since suffered damage and injury and lost public reputation and has been shunned at his place of work, family, general public and the world at large.

  However, in their defense the respondents through their lawyer James Nangwala and Diana Kwesiga submitted that the publications complained of were made on an occasion of qualified privilege of which, when established, is a complete defense to an action for libel.

  The lawyers argued further the publication is not defamatory since the they had a social, moral and legal duty to make the publication in that respect to the public which similarly had a corresponding moral and social duty to receive the publication. 

Accordingly, they asked court to dismiss Bigirimana’s suit on grounds that some of his prayers were filed out of time and each of the impugned publication was made on an occasion of privilege and is therefore not unlawful. 

However, in his judgement, Justice Ssekaana has agreed with Bigirimana saying that the allegations were very serious and grave in nature. 

“What made it even grave is that the said money was meant for Northern Uganda post-war rehabilitation, the said region having gone through decades of war and trauma,” said Sekaana. “Any person believed to have tampered with the said aid, in the eyes of reasonable and right thinking members of society would be equated to a mass murderer.”

The Judge has further ruled that the evidence on record clearly shows a systematic scheme to report specifically about Bigirimana and this was in a manner that would portray him as the key suspect in the financial scam which was under investigations.

  “The publications seem to excite the public against the plaintiff/Bigirimana to form adverse opinions or exposes him to hatred, contempt or ridicule, or injure him in his employment and thus to cause him to be shunned or avoided in society”, reads Ssekaana’s judgement in part.

The judgement goes on:  “The stories as set in the plaint are twisted, skewed and crafted in a manner which portrayed the plaintiff in a negative sense as a corrupt person under investigations.”  

He further ruled that the stories are materially false and only intended to portray Bigirimana as uncooperative in the investigation of corruption in OPM or that he has something to hide from the public.  

” The reporters failed to appreciate the nature of the fraud and how it was done, and resorted to make conclusive remarks about the plaintiff/Bigirimana as the main suspect since he was the accounting officer and yet the PAC report had set out an elaborate procedure on how the scheme that led to the embezzlement was executed by officials of Ministry of Finance, Bank of Uganda and the Principal Accountant of OPM’, held Ssekaana.

  Accordingly, Ssekaana has issued a permanent injunction restraining the respondents their agents and assignees from publishing further defamatory statements about Bigirimana.

Monitor Publications has also been ordered to publish an apology with equal publicity as the disputed defamatory publications for a period of two weeks at least two times a week.

The Judge has further ordered that the 450 million shillings that is to be paid to Bigirimana in compensation will attract a 10 percent interest effective today until its paid in full.

In March, 2021, the President of Uganda Yoweri Kaguta Museveni filed a defamation case against the same paper and its Editors seeking compensation for the damages caused to him after they published a story saying that Museveni and his inner circle had secretly been given COVID-19 jabs, at the time when there were no vaccines in the country.  

The case is pending hearing before the same Judge, Ssekaana.

Tags: 247 NewsCourtPolitics
ShareTweetSend
Previous Post

EC Warns Against Violence Ahead of Local Gov’t Residual, By-elections

Next Post

Drivers, Operators Protest Sorry State of Mbarara City Park

Dorothy Nalumansi

Dorothy Nalumansi

Next Post

Drivers, Operators Protest Sorry State of Mbarara City Park

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Why more Ugandans in diaspora want policy on migrant workers reviewed

UAE stops Issuance of 30-day Visas to Ugandans

October 24, 2022
Kampala Massage

“I have live sex with 18 clients a day” – Kampala massage therapist

October 2, 2022

Muhoozi Promotion is Actually a demotion – Solomon Serwanjja

October 5, 2022

Rap group call out publication for using their image in place of ‘gang’

0

Twitter tweaks video again, adding view counts for some users

0

A beginner’s guide to the legendary Tim Tam biscuit, now available in America

0
Stanbic, Cinemax 190-day promo gives 20% discounts on FlexiPay, Visa Card payments

Stanbic, Cinemax 190-day promo gives 20% discounts on FlexiPay, Visa Card payments

December 4, 2023
COP28: Global and African partners pledge $175m to the Alliance for Green Infrastructure in Africa (AGIA)

COP28: Global and African partners pledge $175m to the Alliance for Green Infrastructure in Africa (AGIA)

December 4, 2023
Who is Makata, new chief finance and value management offcier

Who is Makata, new chief finance and value management offcier

December 4, 2023
ADVERTISEMENT
News 247

Copyright © 2021 24/7 Broadcasting Ltd. [email protected]

  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • Virtual Exhibition
    • Politics
    • Business
    • World
    • Science
  • Tech
    • Apps
    • Gear
    • Mobile
    • Startup
  • Entertainment
    • Music
    • Movie
    • Sports
  • Lifestyle
    • Food
    • Fashion
    • Health
    • Travel
  • Shot Stories
  • Fact Checker

Copyright © 2021 24/7 Broadcasting Ltd. [email protected]