• Latest
  • Trending
  • All
  • News
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Science
  • World
  • Lifestyle
  • Tech
Crane Bank

What Next for Sudhir, BOU After “End of Crane Bank Battle” ?

February 14, 2022
Investigation; Why hunger, poverty continues to devour Karamoja despite dozens of gov’t programmes

Investigation; Why hunger, poverty continues to devour Karamoja despite dozens of gov’t programmes

June 3, 2023
UBOS trains supervisors for pilot census, fire two staff

UBOS trains supervisors for pilot census, fire two staff

June 2, 2023
Elle Parle

Elle Parle women’s open hosts 3rd edition

June 2, 2023
Police FC qualifies for Uganda Cup final for the first time in their history

Police FC qualifies for Uganda Cup final for the first time in their history

June 2, 2023
child murders

Police arrest five over vandalism

June 2, 2023
Govt should translate PDM documents to local languages -report

Govt should translate PDM documents to local languages -report

June 2, 2023
Why speaker Among is  rooting for payment of village health teams

Why speaker Among is rooting for payment of village health teams

May 30, 2023
Butiki League match day 2 of season 3 attracts a huge crowd

Butiki League match day 2 of season 3 attracts a huge crowd

May 29, 2023
We need to include the male in reproductive health education -Kadaga

We need to include the male in reproductive health education -Kadaga

May 29, 2023
UTB launches the explore Northern Uganda campaign

UTB launches the explore Northern Uganda campaign

May 26, 2023
ADVERTISEMENT
News 24/7
  • Home
  • News
    • All
    • Business
    • Politics
    • Science
    • World
    UBOS trains supervisors for pilot census, fire two staff

    UBOS trains supervisors for pilot census, fire two staff

    Elle Parle

    Elle Parle women’s open hosts 3rd edition

    Police FC qualifies for Uganda Cup final for the first time in their history

    Police FC qualifies for Uganda Cup final for the first time in their history

    child murders

    Police arrest five over vandalism

    Govt should translate PDM documents to local languages -report

    Govt should translate PDM documents to local languages -report

    Why speaker Among is  rooting for payment of village health teams

    Why speaker Among is rooting for payment of village health teams

    We need to include the male in reproductive health education -Kadaga

    We need to include the male in reproductive health education -Kadaga

    UTB launches the explore Northern Uganda campaign

    UTB launches the explore Northern Uganda campaign

    Police station attackers have political motives – Enanga

    Police officer shoots self to death

    Museveni rallies Masaka farmers on building businesses for legacy

    Museveni rallies Masaka farmers on building businesses for legacy

    Trending Tags

    • Donald Trump
    • Future of News
    • Climate Change
    • Market Stories
    • Election Results
    • Flat Earth
  • Entertainment
    • All
    • Gaming
    • Movie
    • Music
    • Sports
    Police FC qualifies for Uganda Cup final for the first time in their history

    Police FC qualifies for Uganda Cup final for the first time in their history

    20 years later, Newcastle United lands champions league glory

    20 years later, Newcastle United lands champions league glory

    Veteran Patrick Ochan vows to inspire Kigezi HomeBoyz FC to defend their Regional trophy

    Veteran Patrick Ochan vows to inspire Kigezi HomeBoyz FC to defend their Regional trophy

    Uganda Cranes to host Algeria in Cameroon

    Uganda Cranes to host Algeria in Cameroon

    What you missed at Butiki League season three day one

    What you missed at Butiki League season three day one

    Hundreds of runners at the 2023 Kabaka Birthday run (1)

    Thousands Throng Lubiri for the 10th Airtel – Kabaka Birthday Run

    10-man Express FC complete a double against BUL FC

    10-man Express FC complete a double against BUL FC

    Kataka fans injure 6 Adjumani FC players in melee

    Kataka fans injure 6 Adjumani FC players in melee

    Rogers Mato voted USPA Sportive/Assist personality for the month of March

    Rogers Mato voted USPA Sportive/Assist personality for the month of March

    Salim Jamal documentary: the goal keeper chronicles how he has managed to achieve

    Salim Jamal documentary: the goal keeper chronicles how he has managed to achieve

  • Watch Now
  • Sports
  • Shot Stories
  • Fact Checker
No Result
View All Result
News 24/7
No Result
View All Result
Home Business and Finance

What Next for Sudhir, BOU After “End of Crane Bank Battle” ?

URN.”The implication of this decision is that Sudhir Ruparelia has received back Crane Bank ‘the company’ and not the ‘financial institution’. Crane Bank ceased being a financial institution after receivership wherein all its assets were sold to DFCU," says lawyer Isha Baguma

Dorothy Nalumansi by Dorothy Nalumansi
February 14, 2022
in Business and Finance
Reading Time: 5 mins read
0
Crane Bank
ADVERTISEMENT

The decision by the Supreme Court of Uganda that Crane Bank Ltd reverts to owners Sudhir Ruparelia and co-shareholders raised public excitement, for various reasons, including an assumed return of the bank into the banking industry.

ADVERTISEMENT

Other views were concerns about the financial implications of the decision on the national Treasury and on Ugandans generally, while others pondered what it meant for other banks closed under related or similar circumstances.

At least seven commercial banks have been closed in about two decades on grounds of mismanagement, and the mandate by the BOU to protect the customer’s deposits, among others.  Only Crane Bank has managed to take on the central bank on its decisions in courts of law.

ADVERTISEMENT

Some offenses by the owners or managers of the closed banks were said to include financial mismanagement, insider lending, depletion of working capital and family or single-holder ownership.

The laws in question including the Financial Institutions Act, the Bank of Uganda Act, and a host of others laws, regulations and policies, give BOU the powers to seize a commercial bank, or close it altogether when it senses violation of the laws.

Crane Bank, like a host of previous cases, was also accused of most of these offenses, including theft.

These allegations by BOU against Crane still stand, until a court or a forensic audit clears the owners of any wrongdoing.

The case against the Crane Bank owners; Sudhir Ruparelia and Meera Investments, was dismissed at all levels on technical grounds, not their proof of innocence.

But the regulator, BOU did not follow the right procedures when it seized and attempted to liquidate CBL.

So, legally, now that Crane Bank Ltd exists and the shareholders must receive the company back, according to the courts of law, is the bank about to resume its operations? Experts say, no.

“It’s important to note the case was dismissed on a technicality and not on its merits and even still the issue of whether Bank of Uganda illegally placed Crane Bank into receivership was not in contention and therefore no decision was made to that effect,” Isha Baguma, a Corporate, Commercial, Tax and Litigation Lawyer, says.

One of the technical grounds was that since receivership by law should be concluded within 12 months, BOU’s receivership of Crane Bank Ltd also ended on 20th January 2018 and therefore the management of the company should be returned to its shareholders.

In 2016, BOU commissioned a study into the alleged offenses and the subsequent “Report on the preliminary forensic review at Crane Bank” by PricewaterhouseCoopers recommended the prosecution of Crane Bank board of directors, investors, and senior management for “flaunting Uganda’s banking laws and committing various financial crimes.”

This is yet to be done.

“The implication of this decision is that Sudhir Ruparelia has received back Crane Bank ‘the company’ and not the ‘financial institution’ as Crane Bank ceased being a financial institution after receivership wherein all its assets were sold to DFCU,”  says Baguma.

In other words, Mr Ruparelia and his co-owners will get back the incorporation papers of “Crane Bank Ltd,” but not the business assets which are now owned by DFCU, or the license to operate as a bank which was effectively revoked by BOU, unless he successfully challenges the revocation, too.

Also, the courts did not say whether or not Mr Ruparelia and Meera Investments or CBL management were at fault or innocent, and therefore they are not yet cleared to own or operate a bank in Uganda.

But even then, “the third schedule of the FIA is very clear on the test and for as long as you were a director of a bank placed under receivership by BOU you can’t pass the test,” says Baguma.

As of 2016, Sudhir Ruperelia and his family controlled 48.7 percent of the company, and White Sapphire Ltd based in Mauritius, owned 47.33 percent, while the rest belonged to some Ugandans.

So, what did Sudhir and Meera win, and what did BOU and the taxpayer lose?

Crane Bank Ltd can now press the BOU to give accountability of the assets it seized (which were transferred to DFCU).

Unfortunately for the regulator, it might not succeed in accounting for them.

“There are no records of the assets that BOU took, there are no minutes of meetings that should have taken place before the sale of the assets,” said Lawyer Abdul Katuntu, who also led a parliamentary probe into BOU’s handling of mismanaged banks.

As of 31 December 2015, Crane Bank’s assets were worth 1.81 trillion shillings, with shareholders’ equity of 281.43 billion shillings, according to official records on the banking industry.

In October 2015, it had more than 750,000 customers.

The Bank’s assets were acquired by DFCU Bank in January 2017 at a cost of 200 billion shillings, on grounds that it was undercapitalized as declared by the regulator, BOU.

It is also not clear how much the appointed administrator of the Bank, Mr Katimbo Mugwanya brought into the company when he was running it before BOU handed the assets over to DFCU.

The Bank of Uganda will also have to pay costs of the case at all the three levels, which are yet to be determined.

They include court costs at the the High Court, Court of Appeal and Supreme Court, as well as lawyers fees.

On top of BOU having a fully fledged legal department, it opted to hire a private law firm, Byamugisha and Co Advocates and it not yet clear what their bill is.

The ruling of the courts could also trigger action for redress by the owners of the banks that were closed by BOU before Crane Bank.

They include the Cooperative Bank Ltd, Teefe Bank, International Credit Bank, Commercial Bank of Commerce, Global Trust Bank and Greenland Bank.

According to findings by the MP Katuntu-led Committee on Commissions, Statutory Authorities and State Enterprises -COSASE probe, there are no records on the processes that led to the closure of these banks.

for more click here

ShareTweetSend
Previous Post

Agriculture Minister Discourages Small Holder Farmers in Kigezi from Tea Growing

Next Post

Implementation Paralysis, Limited Funding Blighted Kajubi Reforms-Educationists

Dorothy Nalumansi

Dorothy Nalumansi

Next Post
William Senteza Kajubi

Implementation Paralysis, Limited Funding Blighted Kajubi Reforms-Educationists

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Why more Ugandans in diaspora want policy on migrant workers reviewed

UAE stops Issuance of 30-day Visas to Ugandans

October 24, 2022
Kampala Massage

“I have live sex with 18 clients a day” – Kampala massage therapist

October 2, 2022

Muhoozi Promotion is Actually a demotion – Solomon Serwanjja

October 5, 2022
Immaculate Kibekyenga Corruption unit

Anti Corruption unit saves Girl from Saudi Organ Harvest racket

5
4.8 Billion Collected in Traffic Police Operations

4.8 Billion Collected in Traffic Police Operations

3
Doctor on ebola frontline speaks to us annonymously

“We are denied PPE, threatened and intimidated” – Exclusive Interview with a doctor on the Ebola Frontline

3
Investigation; Why hunger, poverty continues to devour Karamoja despite dozens of gov’t programmes

Investigation; Why hunger, poverty continues to devour Karamoja despite dozens of gov’t programmes

June 3, 2023
UBOS trains supervisors for pilot census, fire two staff

UBOS trains supervisors for pilot census, fire two staff

June 2, 2023
Elle Parle

Elle Parle women’s open hosts 3rd edition

June 2, 2023
ADVERTISEMENT
News 247

Copyright © 2021 24/7 Broadcasting Ltd. [email protected]

  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • Virtual Exhibition
    • Politics
    • Business
    • World
    • Science
  • Tech
    • Apps
    • Gear
    • Mobile
    • Startup
  • Entertainment
    • Music
    • Movie
    • Sports
  • Lifestyle
    • Food
    • Fashion
    • Health
    • Travel
  • Shot Stories
  • Fact Checker

Copyright © 2021 24/7 Broadcasting Ltd. [email protected]